San Diego State University’s Independent Student Newspaper Since 1913

The Daily Aztec

Letter from College Republicans to Muslim Student Association generates backlash

San+Diegans+at+a+vigil+for+Heather+Heyer%2C+the+woman+killed+protesting+the+%22Unite+the+Right%22+demonstrations+in+Virginia
San Diegans at a vigil for Heather Heyer, the woman killed protesting the

San Diegans at a vigil for Heather Heyer, the woman killed protesting the "Unite the Right" demonstrations in Virginia

Will Fritz

Will Fritz

San Diegans at a vigil for Heather Heyer, the woman killed protesting the "Unite the Right" demonstrations in Virginia

by Will Fritz, News Editor

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The San Diego State College Republicans sent out a statement requesting the SDSU Muslim Student Association denounce “radical Islamic terrorism” Thursday, Aug. 17.

The College Republicans’ statement was issued the same day as the terror attacks in Barcelona, Spain, which were attributed to individuals believed to be associated with the Islamic State.

“We ask the president of your organization to publicly condemn this morning’s acts of radical Islamic terrorism in Spain and those acts similar in nature,” the College Republicans’ statement read. “If this request is not made, we ask that the president of the Muslim Student Association and any remaining executive officers not in compliance resign immediately.”

The MSA did not immediately respond to the College Republicans’ letter, but thanked their supporters days later on Sunday, Aug. 20, for “numerous amounts of positive messages and comments regarding the distasteful letter that was sent to us.”

“Your kind words and willingness to stand up against injustice has showed our members and Muslim students from other universities around the country that we are not alone,” the MSA post – which never addressed the College Republicans – read. “Despite hundreds of attempts to stifle our voice and activism, the MSA continues to be a uniting force on campus.”

The MSA’s post also said the organization would like to express support for “victims of white supremacy, nationalism and terrorism.”

Representatives from the Muslim Student Association declined to formally be interviewed, but said in a Facebook message that the College Republicans’ letter was insensitive to the “current political climate of white supremacy and nationalism,” and an attempt to “distract and bait” the MSA at the beginning of a new semester.

“Muslims, people of color and other marginalized groups are already threatened on a national level, and acts such as this letter do nothing more than bring that threat to our college campuses,” the message read. “The MSA is committed, as always, to standing against hate, racism and oppression.”

SDSU College Republicans President Brandon Jones said the MSA’s post wasn’t what his organization was looking for.

“They thanked those in the community who support them and then went right back to playing the victim,” he said.

The College Republicans also received condemnation from SDSU Young Democratic Socialists of America, who called the letter to the MSA a “cruel and bigoted act.”

“By insinuating that MSA members will be considered terrorist sympathizers unless they condemn an attack they had nothing to do with, your organization is making Muslim students feel even more unsafe on their own campus,” the YDSA said in a statement posted to Twitter Aug. 18.

“Where was the College Republicans’ condemnation when Identity Evropa, a white nationalist hate group, plastered their propaganda posters and stickers all over campus?” the YDSA statement continued.

Though the College Republicans did not condemn Identity Evropa when their flyers began appearing around campus in fall 2016 – a time when Jones was not yet SDSUCR president – the College Republicans did issue a statement Aug. 12 denouncing the “Unite the Right” demonstrations in Charlottesville, Virginia, where a counter-protester was killed Friday, Aug. 18.

In the days since the College Republicans statement was issued, Jones said he received at least 10 threats via phone calls, Facebook messages or text messages.

One individual sent a text message to Jones referring to him as a “vile piece of an excuse as a human being (sic)” and told him to “watch your back every step you take.”

The individual would not go on the record with The Daily Aztec.

Jones defended his organization against accusations of racism, saying the College Republicans only intended to “level the playing field” in a university environment that he sees as antagonistic to conservative values.

“We’re just trying to create the same standard for everybody,” Jones said.

“Obviously, College Republicans – Republicans in general – are held to a different standard than other organizations,” he said. “I think that the political climate and the cultural climate in America, obviously on college campuses, leans to the left. I think that’s apparent to everybody.”

Jones said the College Republicans were not implying the MSA is responsible for the Barcelona attacks.

“We are simply looking for them to condemn what happened there, much like we condemned the events that took place in Charlottesville,” he said.

Jones also said, in light of the reaction to his organization’s statement, he intends to organize a round table discussion between various student organizations on campus to focus on how the community can “combat racism, hate (and) violence of all types, whether it be white supremacy or radical Islamic terrorism.”

“I think the best thing to do is to all get together, because we’re one big community, and we need to work on this together,” Jones said. “We’ll get the details together, and if they choose to show up, they’ll be more than welcome. If not, that’s also their choice.”

 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

8 Comments

8 Responses to “Letter from College Republicans to Muslim Student Association generates backlash”

  1. Sai Zamingir on August 23rd, 2017 8:34 am

    Check your spelling

    [Reply]

  2. Ted W Bishop on August 23rd, 2017 2:21 pm

    San Diego State College Republicans should not expect the Muslim Student Association denounce “radical Islamic terrorism”. Muslim student are not responsible for radical fringe actions. Nor should any group have to denounce or apologize for radical fringe actions of those with some shared similarities. Stop stereotyping everyone into tribal groups and have better individual communication.

    [Reply]

    Donell Reply:

    Lol the letter was a response to their club being demanded to denounce the nazis in Charlotte. Obviously no group should have to answer for the actions of radicals, that was the point of this letter

    [Reply]

    Kevin McNamara Reply:

    That is absurd. Everyone denounces Nazis but most have been dead for years. Do you care about real terrorists? Cop killers who are usually black. Or are they special in your world.

    [Reply]

    Penny Reply:

    Then why is the MSM insisting President Trump and the GOP condemn Nazi’s and the KKK, even though there is no affiliation? Another double standard.

    [Reply]

    Hal Reply:

    Can you spell “left-wing hypocrite”?

    [Reply]

    yankeefan Reply:

    “Muslim students are not responsible for radical fringe actions. Nor should any group have to denounce or apologize for radical fringe actions of those with some shared similarities.”

    Well then you can’t hold President Trump responsible for the violence committed by te KKK and the Neo Nazis in Charlottsvile VA

    [Reply]

  3. Frank Davis on August 23rd, 2017 11:14 pm

    Wait, let me get this straight – the left gets all upset, demanding Tump specifically name and condemn nazi groups, but the left gets offended when Muslims are asked to denounce radical islamists?

    Lotta hypocrisy going on here.

    [Reply]

Commenting on our site is a privilege. We want our readers to add their point of view to every story but ask that they keep their comments relevant to the topic at hand. We will remove comments and possibly ban users who do the following: (1) Use vulgar or racist language, (2) Threaten harm of any sort to staff, commenters or the subject of an article, and (3) Leave spam in their comment. If you have questions about these rules, please contact our Editor in Chief at: editor@thedailyaztec.com

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.